Monday, April 19, 2010

Identity crisis, the sequel

Today at lunch I met a Chinese English teacher who teaches most of my classes Hotel English.  He was really nice even though his English was spotty and probably worse than my Chinese.  I was glad to meet my Hotel English counterpart and I think he was glad to meet me because my students had been telling him about me.

I asked him what they thought of me, forgetting how blunt the Chinese can be at times, and was told that some of the students think that it is a "pity that [I] am not a blonde eyed, blue haired American girl."
Well, um, gee, thanks for the compliment?  
I understand that the students would ideally like a "blonde eyed, blue haired American girl," but I'd like to think that after my students' initial period of time when they were trying to figure out what exactly an Asian-American was, that they now see me as an American.  At the beginning, it was almost as if I was a lost Chinese girl who was shipwrecked on the far away island of Singapore, was shipped to America in a box by accident, and has finally returned to the motherland, the Middle Country, the Peoples' Republic of China.  Now my students forget I actually speak Chinese and have no questions that I am American.

At first I was asked things like "Why is your hair black?" and "Are your parents Chinese?" which seem pretty obvious to us, but to many Chinese people there is no concept of the hyphenated Asian-American.  I thought most of my students had gotten over this by now.
I guess they haven't. 
I'm giving my students the benefit of the doubt, though, since I do have so much direct contact with them and face-to-face time with me speaking American English and absolutely no Chinese.  The way I walk, dress, hold myself, and even write my number '6' (a constant war between me and my students) is completely different.  Maybe it was just this one teacher who did not expect the 'foreign teacher Alison' to look so Chinese.  Perhaps he himself has more prejudices than my students and would not learn English from me, but rather a white person even if they are an uncaring and overall crappy teacher.

These are the frustrations I have faced almost every day here.  I am an Asian-American.  I am Chinese.  I am a U.S. citizen, have voted in the past two elections, hold a drivers license, and have completed thirteen years in the American educational system.

The thing is that China is so very homogeneous.  There may be fifty-one minority groups, but most (92% according to Wikipedia) of the people you see are Han.    There is no Korean-Chinese or Canadian-Chinese.  Only Chinese.

The plus side is that there is a word in Chinese "华人“ (overseas Chinese) which indicates I am of Chinese decent, but my family settled in Singapore all those decades ago.  Step one, check.  Step two is to explain how I can be both American and Chinese at the same time.
Cue shrill sound of a bomb dropping and exploding.  
And that's where the logic ends.  So here I am, somewhere between fully American and fully Chinese to the, um, real Chinese?  Cool.  Thanks guys.  I appreciate it.  I'm just going to continue to teach you American English with some hopes that you too one day will go to America, and possibly even have your own little Asian-American children yourself.  That will be the day.

5 comments:

Kate said...

Oh man! Gotta love the bluntness of other cultures... I wonder if they would be disappointed with someone like me, who isn't Asian-American but also not "blond eyed and blue haired". Who knows.

Anyway, sorry that your students want to assign you to a very narrow box and can't understand any sort of wonderful hybrid identity! Seems like you have good perspective though, so just remember that before too long you'll be back here with all sorts of hyphenated and other identities!

Sarah said...

Imagine what an enigma I'd be if I were over there.

Alison said...

Kate, no they wouldn't be disappointed with you. We had a brunette from California last term and they loved her! They have this weird assumption that all Americans are blonde, but basically if you're white, it's ok.

Sarah, I still don't know what to do with you. =P

mark y. goh said...

interesting post. i have experienced that here with chinese and even chinese-americans, our family history is just too complicated then you throw in straits chinese and the odd mixing over the generations...

cant wait to visit the motherland with my blond, blue eyed wife!

Sarah said...

I'd like to add that I get a lot of confusion even over here in the USA. At work, I had a client ask which one I was (i.e., Japanese or Chinese). When I told her she was Korean, she kept asking if that was Japan or China. I guess she thought Asian = one or the other, and had never heard of Korea... scary.

I also get asked a lot if I'll cook the clients Chinese food, when I tell them I'm adopted from Korea, they keep asking if I can speak Chinese... fail.